Join Our Mailing List
Email:
For Email Marketing you can trust

EDITORIAL: What Government Is, When Words Have No Meaning

What is government, if words have no meaning?

This is the question that Jared Lee Loughner asked Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords of Arizona, the one that she was not able to answer, the last question posed in Loughner's Youtube video series.  

Many media commentators have characterized Loughner's writings as complete, rambling nonsense.  Some have said one cannot rationalize with someone who themselves is irrational.

But I think to miscount Loughner that way would be a mistake.  It's the easy thing to do; it's the safe thing to do; but it's a mistake.

What Loughner did was inexcusable, horrendous, repulsive, shocking, and morally wrong.

But if we as a society do not take time to examine Loughner's message, we risk tragedies like this happening again.

In the human body, if you have a pain, it's a message to the whole body that something is wrong somewhere.  If society is like an organism, then we too are experiencing a pain, a horrible, unjustifiable pain, but perhaps a pain that is a symptom of a real problem.

So I would like to address the question of what is government, if words have no meaning, because I think the exercise could be valuable.

First of all, do words have meaning?  The answer is, yes, but only yes with an asterisk.  And the asterisk is, words have a meaning that we construct as a society to fit our purposes.  We as a society create and recreate through our actions a shared understanding of what reality is.

That means, words like democracy, government, freedom, do not come predefined through nature, God, or destiny.

And that takes us to by the people, of the people, for the people.

Government is something we create with words which we also create.  And so, I think that was part of what Loughner was trying to convey- some frustration that the citizenry has lost touch with the fact that they, and they alone, create, define, and legitimize our form of democratic governance in the United States of America.

If you look back to the writings of Thomas Hobbes, a Western political thinker, in 1671, he noted, "the most noble and profitable invention of all other was that of speech, consisting of names or appellations, and their connexion; whereby men register their thoughts, recall them when they are past, and also declare them one to another for mutual utility and conversation; without which there had been amongst men neither Commonwealth, nor society, nor contract, nor peace, no more than amongst lions, bears, and wolves."

A classical political thinker like Hobbes found it necessary to define language itself before daring to define government.  So from that standpoint, Loughner's question made quite a bit of sense.  It was a hypothetical question, though, because words, of course, do have meaning, a meaning that we can deconstruct, perhaps 
reconstruct.

That Congresswoman Giffords was unable to respond to the question is understandable because it was already a hypothetical question.  He probably could have explained it better, but he had no grounds to be upset that he did not get an answer that day, let alone to go on a murderous rampage.

I believe--and am deeply concerned and troubled that--there are many young people who perceive such a disconnection between the ordinary citizenry and the government.

What's worse, I worry that this alienation and estrangement has been seized upon and capitalized in a cynical, insidious way by political forces who do not favor the ordinary citizenry.

It is up to us all to ensure that the next generation of citizens in our democracy have a meaningful understanding of how public policy affects their lives, and how they can engage in the democratic process.  For some parents, that will mean educating themselves first, and providing their children with a civic foundation that they never had.

If words have no meaning, then government is nothing.  But if words have a meaning that we create, then government is a tool that we create, and can change at our will.  I think we would do well to remember that.

About the author:

Matthew Cardinale is the News Editor of the Atlanta Progressive News, an online news service founded in 2005.  He has an MA in Sociology from University of California, Irvine, 2005, and an MPA from Univesity of New Orleans, 2007.  He is reachable at matthew@atlantaprogressivenews.com.


Comments (12)

Sandy Eyl
Said this on 1-25-2011 At 06:53 pm

What an important message, for everyone to pay some attention to. It really extends beyond any locality to all of the United States.

davidlampad
Said this on 1-4-2014 At 02:49 am

What a fantastic post ! it was absolutely actual informative.I attending advanced in account added of your assignment post, And accomplish you abiding that i will bookmark your post how ever i can appear a back latter.
Plastic valves

Jonson
Said this on 1-24-2014 At 08:21 am

I would like to appreciate your hard work you did write this post, Thanks for sharing this valuable post.
Truflo

linda99
Said this on 4-27-2014 At 01:09 am

An interesting post. I think your comments are expressive as well as founded. Think most people agreed on this thread.
Truflo water meter

Johnson Pearson
Said this on 6-6-2014 At 08:09 pm

When wanting to become a nurse then you must know that medical and the pearson exam with rn rate will be nursing and the answers rate for the exam showing the ncles is the<a 
href="http://powerstarvoice.com/nclex-pearson-exam-questions-passing-rn-answers-rate/"> http://powerstarvoice.com/nclex-pearson-exam-quest... so the passing rn and the registered nurse and the rate in which we pass is truely incredible considering the position you would have to be note and the questions of the ncle...Great Site Friend . nclex is a test that will blow your mind and the pearson questions is something that will startle you to want the answers of the nclex.

When wanting to become a nurse then you must know that medical and the pearson exam with rn rate will be nursing and the answers rate for the exam showing the ncles is the http://powerstarvoice.com/nclex-pearson-exam-questions-passing-rn-answers-rate/"so the passing rn and the registered nurse and the rate in which we pass is truely incredible considering the position you would have to be note and the questions of the ncle...Great Site Friend . nclex is a test that will blow your mind and the pearson questions is something that will startle you to want the answers of the nclex.

linda99
Said this on 6-12-2014 At 09:48 am

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information?
Hayward Plastic y-Strainers

Said this on 7-9-2014 At 12:19 pm

I have visited to this site multiple times and everytime I find useful jobs for me so I would suggest please come to this site and take the chance from here.
<a href=http://www.iconprotech.com/proalert1000.html>Process Alarm</a>

linda99
Said this on 7-23-2014 At 08:00 am

The only difference is that the state will not have blood on its hands and no one would be killed by mistake should new evidence prove that a convict was in fact innocent.

Levelpro

linda99
Said this on 7-23-2014 At 09:15 am

I am so much excited after reading your blog. Your blog is very much innovative and much helpful for any industry as well as for person.
Hayward Actuator

polo
Said this on 7-24-2014 At 10:27 pm

Best friend successive good years, Gucci Shoes Factory, winter spent in Sanya, Monster Beats Outlet, so winter home, seems to be nowhere in sight, North Jackets Outlet, both a little rusty, Nike Air Max Shoes, but also very cordial, Burberry Outlet Online, forward to tonight, feather-like snow, MCM Bags Outlet, drifts underground, Hermes Handbags Outlet, looking at that the floc, Louis Vuitton Outlet, fly like snow Ling, Michael Kors Outlet Online, eloquent, Polo Outlet Online, flying in the sky, Cheap Canada Goose, limp walk downs, strange things, Marc Jacobs Outlet Online, I float thinking lianpian, North Outlet Online, poetic heart wenqing, not help surging surging, Coach Factory Outlet, so I borrowed the winter, Ralph Lauren UK, snows research ink, Longchamp Sacs Sortie, into the mind of inactivity, Michael Kors Outlet, the white snow everywhere, Monster Beats By Dre, wrapped in some different, Ralph Lauren Outlet, kind of scenery, Oakley Sunglaases Outlet, wherever the polo Outlet wind in the faces, of the people, Michael Kors Bags Outlet, who are very Huddled, could not help.Handbags Outlet, http://www.superbagsmarket.com/ Louis Vuitton Outlet Hermes Bags Outlet Prada Outlet Online Chanel Outlet Gucci Outlet Burberry Outlet Online Celine Outlet Online Balenciaga Outlet Online Christian Bior Outlet Chloe Outlet Bvlgari Outlet Bally Outlet Online coach Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet MCM Backpack Outlet Fendi Outlet mulberry Outlet Online Marc Jacobs Outlet Online Miu Miu Outlet Ysl Outlet Tory Burch Outlet Givenchy Outlet Ferragamo Outlet Lancel Outlet Loewe Bags Outlet Tods Outlet Paul Smith Outlet D&G Bags Outlet Alexander Wang Outlet Bottega Veneta Outlet

linda99
Said this on 8-5-2014 At 06:43 am

Thanks a lot for providing individuals with a spectacular possibility to read critical reviews and posts from this site. Simply wanted to write down a word in order to say thanks.
Pro alert alarm

linda99
Said this on 8-5-2014 At 07:15 am

I am full of emotions after reading this post. I really like it and it is good, that author decided to write on this topic. I would like to read his another posts.
levelpro displays

Post a Comment
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
(not publicly displayed)
Reply Notification:
Website:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image:
* Message:

Email to Friend

Fill in the form below to send this oped to a friend:

Email to Friend
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
* Friend's Name:
* Friend's Email:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image
* Message:

Please use this form to contact us
Your Name:
Your Email:
Subject:
Question/Comment: