Join Our Mailing List
For Email Marketing you can trust

Mayor Reed Seeks to Silence National Website

(APN) ATLANTA -- Mayor Kasim Reed is using a high-priced law firm to attempt to silence a national website, Lipstick Alley, after some of its users on an open forum published comments that Reed claims are libelous.

On October 08, 2012, J. Randolph Evans, an attorney with McKenna Long & Aldridge, sent a cease and desist letter to an Internet data center providing hosting for Lipstick Alley.

“This Firm represents the Honorable Kasim Reed, the Mayor of the City of Atlanta.  DEMAND IS HEREBY FORMALLY MADE that Lipstick Alley ( immediately cease and desist publishing any and all statements about Mayor Reed that are false, defamatory, and cause significant harm to his reputation and good name.  Lipstick Alley’s unwarranted actions and baseless allegations have caused and are causing irreparable damage,” the letter states.

“Lipstick Alley has published the following false, malicious and libelous statements, among others, about Mayor Reed,” the letter states, then quoting three examples.

The letter then goes on to outline three posts, dated September 11, April 25, and January 20, 2012, that make statements about the alleged sexual activities and sexual inclinations of the elected mayor of Atlanta, Kasim Reed, and of several high-level city appointees.

“The statements, representations, and false light published by Lipstick Alley are categorically false. There is no factual basis for them.  Instead the facts establish that they are NOT true,” the letter states.

“At this point, any further republication by Lipstick Alley, after receipt of this letter, is a knowing publication of untrue statements, and as such, deliberately defamatory communications.  Further republication includes failure to delete the link and/or publish a correction,” the letter states.

“Toward this end, DEMAND is hereby made that Lipstick Alley remove from its website any false and defamatory statement regarding Mayor Reed’s personal life (including, but not limited to, those referenced above) and take aggressive steps to ensure that Lipstick Alley does not publish any false statements of this sort in any subsequent blog posts or other forums on Lipstick Alley,” the letter states.

“Lipstick Alley’s failure to comply with this demand by October 18, 2012, will leave us no choice but to recommend that Mayor Reed pursue all legal causes of action that he might have, which include litigation in which Mayor Reed would pursue damages, attorney’s fees, and costs,” the letter states.

The hosting company then took Lipstick Alley offline, but Lipstick Alley simply put the full website back online using another web hosting company.

On October 17, Paul Alan Levy of the Public Citizen Litigation Group responded to Reed on behalf of Lipstick Alley.

“This letter responds to your October 8, 2012 letter to Lipstick Alley, which you chose to send
not to Lipstick Alley but rather to the Internet data center that hosted Lipstick Alley’s web site at the time of your letter, and to another data center that had previously hosted the site,” Levy wrote.

“Your letter charges Lipstick Alley with legal responsibility for statements posted on Lipstick Alley about the sexual activities and sexual inclinations of the elected mayor of Atlanta, Kasim Reed, and of several high-level city appointees.  You claim that, upon receiving your unsworn contention that these posted statements are false, Lipstick Alley becomes legally responsible for knowing that they are, in fact, false; you demand that Lipstick Alley retract that statements; and you assert that if the statements remain posted on or after October 18, Reed reserves the right to sue Lipstick Alley and, indeed, its former hosting companies for defamation,” Levy wrote.

“Your demands reflect a woeful ignorance of the facts and the law.  Lipstick Alley is a forum that allows members of the public to express their views about public figures such as elected officials, professional athletes, and popular entertainers and writers.  Lipstick Alley’s members are predominantly African American females, but all races and genders are welcome.  Messages are posted on Lipstick Alley without any involvement by the site’s creator, and Lipstick Alley does not express its own views about such subjects.  Each of the statements about which you complain has been placed on Lipstick Alley by one of it users,” Levy wrote.

“Lipstick Alley does not know whether its members are telling the truth about Kasim Reed, any more than it knows whether you are telling the truth when you deny the truth of those statements.  For all we know, the anonymous users of the web site may have personal knowledge of facts they discuss, but I am confident that you yourself have no personal knowledge about whether Reed or any of the other public officials have engaged in the sexual activities mentioned in your letter.  For all of these reasons, Lipstick Alley is in no more position to ‘retract’ the statements that it did not make than it would be to confirm them,” Levy wrote.

“Moreover, a federal statute, 47 U.S.C. 230, makes Lipstick Alley absolutely immune from being held liable for statements placed on its interactive Web site by other information providers, and indeed from being sued for those statements,” Levy wrote.

Levy told APN that his organization is particularly interested in this case because it wants to protect 47 U.S.C. 230, a statute which provides for free speech in open online forums.

Lipstick Alley is run by a woman in Michigan who has no interest in Atlanta politics and possesses no knowledge of Mayor Reed or other city officials.  The website is intended simply to provide an open forum for discussion, primarily for Black women, on a wide range of topics.

Levy said he received a follow-up threat from Evans.  

“There will be a response if you continue down this path.  But, I do not believe it will be the one you want... If you are unwilling to meet your legal obligations, there are other ways to make sure that you do.  You will be receiving a more formal response to you correspondence, and further other actions to assure your compliance with Georgia law, and accountability for the damages including fees that you cause,” Evans wrote.  

However, Levy said he has not received the follow-up letter as promised.

A technology blog, Techdirt, wrote an article about what they referred to as the “spineless web host,” PhoenixNAP, for taking down the original Lipstick Alley site.


Comments (7)

Rick Day
Said this on 10-25-2012 At 09:02 pm

Mayor Buff: "When a City....lights up!"


Sorry, can't look at that Falcon's promo any more without a giggle...

Said this on 10-25-2012 At 10:20 pm

What advertisement! I had never heard of this website. How many hits will his information (false or true?) get now?

Steve Swimmer
Said this on 10-26-2012 At 06:29 am

Notice: I am singing my new “Lipstick, Long, Reed” song.  Here are the words, you can sing along too.

Hey, lipstick..., pay no mind.  In Atlanta many know Clay Long and his bunch (McKenna Long & Aldridge) as this town's heavy hitter influence peddlers.

If I am, or others in the Atlanta know like me, are on your jury we will certainly vote your way in order to help you outrun these heavily influenced speech stifling scurrilous tactics.

Influence peddlers? You bet. Small wonder the likes of Kasim Reed would hire them to hide behind. What a coward, he can’t stand the heat of his own battle.

Al Horn, no longer with us; yet, Atlanta’s favored Civil Rights attorney from yesteryear, made the astute observation that you cannot say “Mayor so-and-so is a crook,” because you can be sued.  However, you can sing Mayor so-and-so is a crook and be protected by the constitution.

So you see dear Free Speech loving friends, just sing your spoken words, as I am doing right now, and you can outrun the influence peddling silk stocking pettifoggers, like Long Aldridge, who sue to keep you silent.

Said this on 10-26-2012 At 02:42 pm

I confess that until I re-read Mr. Evans' threatening communication to me on this blog, which contains the phrase "more formal response to you correspondence," I had not focused on the fact that in addition to displaying poor judgment by making a threat to Lipstick Alley that was bound to increase attention to the gossip that he wants to suppress, Mr. Long also doesn't have his associates proofread his threats before he sends them out.

Steve Swimmer
Said this on 10-27-2012 At 10:27 pm

Mr. Levy, you said: “Mr. Long also doesn't have his associates proofread his threats.”

Proofread?  Are you kidding?  This firm thrives on threats.  And, they are quite capable of carrying them out.

Threats are standard operating procedure for Clay Long and his ilk. They have gotten away with it so long, here in Atlanta, they have forgotten it is illegal; and, of course, they play both sides of the political fence so you know they are short on morals.

Mr. Levy, I beg you, please come to our town and bust their chops.  No firm in town deserves it more.

Here is how it works in this town.  You want a favor from a politico; yet, know an out and out bribe is out of the question.

Sooo…, what to do?  Retain a hired gun, the likes of Long Aldridge, influence peddler, pay an outrageous fee then the dirty part is carefully covered for no one to see; and, seemingly magically you get your favor.

Oh yes, please come to Atlanta and take them to task.  Rest assured, many of us down here will gladly cheer you on.   

Said this on 10-27-2012 At 01:00 pm
Said this on 4-18-2013 At 11:25 pm

La lecture du message de propriétaire Air jordan, mon cœur était en réalité une longue période ne peut pas se calmer, comme Lao Tseu dit: Un son de musique, forme grecque d'éléphant. Je comprends enfin ce qui me manque, yeux profonds du propriétaire que la poursuite persistante de la vérité et le type de propriétaire de la pratique dur idéal. Face aux postes de propriétaire, j'ai été choqué pouvait presque pas bouger, le propriétaire, mais moi-même séjour personnel Nike jordan, malgré le fait que je ne pouvais pas m'empêcher d'ouvrir encore et encore les postes de propriétaire Jordan pas cher, chaque regard comme un propriétaire, un sentiment de satisfaction le nombre de longues pointes excités, je pense toujours, Dieu et la flexibilité dans son paysage de l'extérieur , ainsi que rendent les gens ne savent pas la viande en Mars, les gens persistants faisceau d'usure sonore, trois jours sans une sensation de repos. Propriétaires, vous avez l'air vraiment super. La seule chose que je peux faire, seulement pour aller au-dessus de celui-ci

Air jordan 3


Post a Comment
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
(not publicly displayed)
Reply Notification:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image:
* Message:

Please use this form to contact us
Your Name:
Your Email:

Email to Friend

Fill in the form below to send this news item to a friend:

Email to Friend
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
* Friend's Name:
* Friend's Email:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image
* Message: