Join Our Mailing List
Email:
For Email Marketing you can trust

Open Letter to Council: Disclose Your Secret Vote, The Time Has Come

 

Open Letter to Council: Disclose Your Secret Vote, The Time Has Come
Dear Council Members,
It has been nearly one month since the Supreme Court of Georgia ruled
in my favor in the case of Cardinale v. City of Atlanta (2010CV185775 in Fulton 
County Superior Court; S11G1047 in Supreme Court).  The case is
currently on remittur back to the trial court, where you have discovery
that will soon be due and I am prepared to take depositions.
That is where we are, but I wanted to remind us of where we started and
how we got here.  
In February 2010, you all took a vote during lunch at a Council Retreat
with the intent of depriving the public of the breakdown of the votes 
in the minutes.  I believe the record will show that this meeting was 
not only in violation of the requirement to record those names in the 
minutes--as the Supreme Court has recently ruled is required--but also
a failure to list a vote at all and even more, a quasi-closed meeting.
I believe Councilwoman Felicia Moore (District 9) was trying to make 
the best of a difficult political situation in conducting the so-called straw poll,
and that she, in fact, was on the right side of the underlying issue,
which was related to public comment.
And I believed Moore when she told me that you all [mistakenly] thought that
because it wasn't legislation, the listing of the names was not required
under the Georgia Open Meetings Act.
However, here's the problem: after I pointed out that the Act requires
the listing of votes on all "legislation and other proposals" and that
this would have been an "other proposal," the Law Department came back
and provided a new theory of legal defense that you all also adopted: 
that OCGA 50-14-1(e)(2) did not require a listing of the names in a non-roll call vote.
Well, the Supreme Court disagreed, so not only did your original justification
fall through, but your after-the-fact justification fell through as well.
So, if your mistake was really just a misunderstanding of the
law, you would have looked at the new information and you would have admitted 
your mistake and reversed course.
Instead, you all decided to employ a new rationale, that the listing of names in
non-roll call votes was not required.  This suggests to me a knowing and willful
attempt to deprive the public of the knowledge of the vote you took by
any means necessary.
At this point in time, as I have numerous times and at numerous stages previously,
I am asking you to amend the minutes of the Council Retreat to list, at minimum,
the eight nays.  I don't see why what should be such a problem, seeing as how
the eight nays have already told me privately who they are: Carla Smith (District 1),
Kwanza Hall (District 2), Cleta Winslow (District 4), Natalyn Archibong (District 5),
Yolanda Adrean (District 8), Felicia Moore (District 9), CT Martin (District 10),
and Michael Julian Bond (Post 1-at-large).
As you know, it concerns me greatly as a citizen and taxpayer of the City
of Atlanta, that you all have spent probably tens of thousands of taxpayer dollars in 
defending your perceived right to first, a secret vote, and then, fraudulent,
deceptive minutes.  If you are also concerned in any way about the taxpayers,
I would urge you to enter into a Consent Decree with me in this case.  I would
ask the Council to amend the minutes of the Council Retreat; and to enact legislation
specifying that, at a minumum, the minutes of all future meetings of the Council and its 
committees shall record the names of those voting against the proposal or abstaining,
basically letting the public know that we don't have to worry about you all doing
this again.
On the day that City Attorney Cathy Hampton was confirmed almost two years ago, 
I commented on her confirmation at the Committee on Council, where among other thigs, I urged her
to support more settlements of cases out of court.  So it is in that spirit,
out of my ongoing concern for the taxpayers, that I hope to hear from you all
soon regarding resolving this case.
Best wishes,
Matthew Charles Cardinale
News Editor, Atlanta Progressive News

Dear Council Members,

It has been nearly one month since the Supreme Court of Georgia ruled in my favor in the case of Cardinale v. City of Atlanta (2010CV185775 in Fulton County Superior Court; S11G1047 in Supreme Court).  The case is currently on remittur back to the trial court, where you have discovery that will soon be due and I am prepared to take depositions.

That is where we are, but I wanted to remind us of where we started and how we got here.  

In February 2010, you all took a vote during lunch at a Council Retreat with the intent of depriving the public of the breakdown of the votes in the minutes.  I believe the record will show that this meeting was not only in violation of the requirement to record those names in the minutes--as the Supreme Court has recently ruled is required--but also a failure to list a vote at all and even more, a quasi-closed meeting.

I believe Councilwoman Felicia Moore (District 9) was trying to make the best of a difficult political situation in conducting the so-called straw poll, and that she, in fact, was on the right side of the underlying issue, which was related to public comment.

And I believed Moore when she told me that you all [mistakenly] thought that because it wasn't legislation, the listing of the names was not required under the Georgia Open Meetings Act.

However, here's the problem: after I pointed out that the Act requires the listing of votes on all "legislation and other proposals" and that this would have been an "other proposal," the Law Department came back and provided a new theory of legal defense that you all also adopted: that OCGA 50-14-1(e)(2) did not require a listing of the names in a non-roll call vote.

Well, the Supreme Court disagreed, so not only did your original justification fall through, but your after-the-fact justification fell through as well.

So, if your mistake was really just a misunderstanding of the law, you would have looked at the new information and you would have admitted your mistake and reversed course.

Instead, you all decided to employ a new rationale, that the listing of names in non-roll call votes was not required.  This suggests to me a knowing and willful attempt to deprive the public of the knowledge of the vote you took by any means necessary.

At this point in time, as I have numerous times and at numerous stages previously, I am asking you to amend the minutes of the Council Retreat to list, at minimum, the eight nays.  I don't see why that should be such a problem, seeing as how the eight nays have already told me privately who they are: Carla Smith (District 1), Kwanza Hall (District 2), Cleta Winslow (District 4), Natalyn Archibong (District 5), Yolanda Adrean (District 8), Felicia Moore (District 9), CT Martin (District 10), and Michael Julian Bond (Post 1-at-large).

Yes, that's right; think about yourselves for a second.  You're no longer fighting for the right to a secret vote; you've already lost the fight.  What you're now fighting for is the right not to do what you now know the law already requires you to do.  Is that really what you went to Council to spend the taxpayers' money on?

As you know, it concerns me greatly as a citizen and taxpayer of the City of Atlanta, that you all have spent probably tens of thousands of taxpayer dollars in defending your perceived right to first, a secret vote, and then, fraudulent, deceptive minutes.  If you are also concerned in any way about the taxpayers, I would urge you to enter into a Consent Decree with me in this case.  I would ask the Council to amend the minutes of the Council Retreat; and to enact legislation specifying that, at a minimum, the minutes of all future meetings of the Council and its committees shall record the names of those voting against the proposal or abstaining, basically letting the public know that we don't have to worry about you all doing this again.

I'm also concerned, having reviewed the approved minutes of the January 31, 2012, meeting of the Community Development/Human Resources Committee.  Sometimes you specifically write that the vote was unamimous; sometimes you merely write that the motion carried.  Now, the Supreme Court has ruled that if you list no names, it has to mean it's because the vote really was unanimous.  I would ask that the legislation you adopt also provide for a consistent means of recording unanimous votes: either by listing no names, or by saying it is unanimous.  Currently, it's hard to know when you list no names whether it was really unanimous or whether you're just violating the law.

On the day that City Attorney Cathy Hampton was confirmed almost two years ago, I commented on her confirmation at the Committee on Council, where among other things, I urged her to support more settlements of cases out of court.  So it is in that spirit, out of my ongoing concern for the taxpayers, that I hope to hear from you all soon regarding resolving this case.

Best wishes,

Matthew Charles Cardinale

News Editor, Atlanta Progressive News

 


Comments (6)

Replica Handbags
Said this on 1-5-2014 At 10:12 pm

This particular 7 days, WE required the single day at Classic Posts,Designer Replica Handbags the brand new resale store found on Hammond Road within Bangor,Cheap Replicas throughout in the YMCA. Additionally, WE observed the number of areas of the actual exercise experienced enhanced or even not really transformed whatsoever.Handbags Replica Very First, it’s possible to take the kind of supplies getting used.

Said this on 5-8-2014 At 04:02 am

The best playing poker cards cheating devices offered by EYE Poker Cheating Center including poker analyzer, poker predictor,playing cards scanner, scanning camera lens, [url=http://gamehackonline.com/member.php?action=profile&uid=46755]spy pin hole camera lens[/url], marked playing cards and so on.

Said this on 5-15-2014 At 10:23 pm

 is whether you would like to get pleasure from the brilliance of it for extended or not?The solution and determination is exclusively yours! Leopard Print with Delicate Tail Hard Case for iPhone 4S, safeguard your cellular phone from dust, scratches and bumps, captivating leopard print structure with gentle tail, pretty vivid! make anyone eye in your iPhone. Super Trend Lovable Leopard Print with Delicate Tail Difficult Situation for iPhone 4S(rose leopard print) Leopard grain has usually been well known component given that the classical of style.

LV iPhone 4S Leather Case LV Galaxy S4 Cases LV iPad 2 Case

Said this on 8-3-2014 At 10:45 am

YOU day cash enhancements inside Il provides AN growth of home mortgage alternatives for being sensible to boot to, day cash enhancements, Salaryday and to boot Size Personal loans, in conjunction with Automobile Strategy Personal loans. many of us goal aiding you to hunt out the right home mortgage product and to boot solutions to help you to satisfy your current economical wants.

Said this on 8-18-2014 At 10:16 pm

 These Cases are just like your pocket, when you put your cell phone within this Scenario you really feel like you are putting your telephone in pocket. You may conveniently hold your iPhone by installing it in Slip in Pouch Case. Side Go over Conditions: Give designer appears to be like to the iPhone with Side Protect Scenarios.
Gucci iPad Mini Case Louis Vuitton iPad Mini Case Burberry iPad 4 Cases

oakley sunglasses
Said this on 9-6-2014 At 04:12 am

Accompanied michael kors roshe run by timberland uggs on sale a coach handbags christian louboutin shoes own air jordan longchamp Google+ nike free run polo shirts user polo ralph lauren outlet online beats by dre profile longchamp handbags ralph lauren outlet click chanel bags ray ban pas cher the celine handbags canada goose additional p90x3 hermes birkin well birkin bag nike outlet known lancel mont blanc inside toms shoes juicy couture outlet kept christian louboutin outlet giuseppe zanotti sidebar michael kors michaelkors and jerseys sac longchamp next mulberry bags hermes press rolex watches red bottom shoes pages air jordan juicy couture of hollister gucci content. burberry factory outlet chanel purses Any sac louis vuitton polo ralph lauren outlet online time roshe run pas cher ralph lauren given lululemon outlet moncler outlet your uggs boots longchamp outlet online regional nike huaraches abercrombie and fitch industry louis vuitton bags louis vuitton or ugg uk ralph lauren outlet perhaps lancel pas cher longchamp position michael kors handbags nike air max decision longchamp outlet scarpe hogan simply hermes pas cher ugg pas cher click uggs ralph lauren business kate spade outlet online nike free pas cher enterprise louis vuitton converse afterward new balance shoes replica watches occupy ray ban uk prada outlet online generally north face jackets coach outlet industry abercrombie and fitch ray ban,ray ban sunglasses,rayban,ray bans,ray ban outlet,ray-ban,raybans,ray ban wayfarer,ray-ban sunglasses,raybans.com,ray ban sunglasses outlet,rayban sunglasses,cheap ray ban number. longchamp polo ralph lauren pas cher Comprehend sac longchamp pas cher prada shoes to mcm handbags louboutin outlet work tiffany and co toms shoes outlet with tory burch outlet online louboutin shoes the sac michael kors karen millen uk primary nike factory ugg australia small louis vuitton uk michael kors handbags business uggs outlet abercrombie and cell nike roshe run rosh run phone moncler nike trainers number toms outlet air jordan pas cher along kate spade uggs on sale with ralph lauren outlet online true religion jeans to louis vuitton pas cher polo ralph lauren outlet stay coach outlet coach factory away michael kors bags abercrombie from beach wedding dresses michael kors canada 08 tiffanys beats headphones prefix nike huarache reebok skyscape if nfl jerseys true religion outlet you nike free run michaelkors.com can.. timberland pas cher louboutin To prada shoes michael kors handbags clearance start nike free run pas cher converse outlet safely nike roshe run hollister uk and nike free sac lancel effectively, m a c cosmetics louis vuitton get michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors outlet,michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet online,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,michaelkors.com,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors gucci outlet online an north face outlet nike roshe run individual's mont blanc pens polo ralph lauren browse air max canada goose on new balance pas cher abercrombie and fitch her longchamp canada goose jackets behalf uggs on sale rayban hand hollister michael kors your nike free run louis vuitton purses five canada goose longchamp pas cher hands burberry handbags moncler must tory burch handbags ugg boots be longchamp handbags michael kors outlet online over nike roshes louboutin the ralph lauren pas cher mulberry outlet spine abercrombie and fitch michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors outlet,michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet online,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,michaelkors.com,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors connected roshe runs nike air max with prom dresses oakley pas cher your ralph lauren polo tn pas cher ex hollister france hogan personally. longchamp outlet michael kors outlet online sale Caress air max air max the air max polo ralph lauren outlet flash oakley christian louboutin shoes within louboutin shoes longchamp bags rounded ralph lauren outlet online louboutin activity lululemon ugg australia on air max pas cher ralph lauren polo her bottes ugg hermes birkin bag behalf louis vuitton bags borse louis vuitton the ugg nike roshe company. longchamp free run And herve leger hermes belt then ray ban longchamp bags store yoga pants jimmy choo outlet all michael kors purses tory burch outlet of ugg outlet new balance the canada goose outlet nike free woman true religion coach factory outlet kiddy true religion valentino shoes hands sac longchamp true religion outlet along polo ralph lauren outlet nike air max with air max ugg soldes your true religion outlet burberry outlet entire polo ralph lauren cheap wedding dresses all canada goose ray bans 5 longchamp pliage burberry pas cher to instyler ionic styler ugg australia locate mac makeup nike shoes a chanel outlet abercrombie by michael kors outlet kate spade handbags just coach outlet store montre homme squeezing gucci shoes gucci belts snugly ugg outlet montre femme nevertheless evening dresses louis vuitton handbags naturally mulberry handbags sac hermes beginning moncler louboutin outlet within jimmy choo ralph lauren outlet the louis vuitton abercrombie and fitch UK starting ray ban sunglasses north face jackets point soccer jerseys oakley from mulberry oakley sunglasses,oakley vault,oakleys,oakley sunglasses cheap,oakley.com,sunglasses outlet,cheap oakley,cheap oakley sunglasses,oakley outlet,cheap sunglasses,oakley prescription glasses,fake oakleys,oakley sunglasses outlet,oakley glasses,oakley store,fake oakley,oakley sale,cheap oakleys,discount oakley sunglasses the vans pas cher juicy couture woman louboutin polo shirts hand converse chaussure louboutin soon air max hogan sito ufficiale you tory burch shoes longchamp handbags arrive reebok outlet polo ralph lauren at ugg ray ban the longchamp outlet online bridesmaid dresses end.. gucci outlet jordan shoes He homecoming dresses michael kors outlet or mac cosmetics uggs boots she coach bags wedding dresses taken nike roshe maccosmetics.com part abercrombie balance shoes within north face outlet air max no hogan outlet salvatore ferragamo less polo outlet louboutin pas cher than lululemon canada ghd 10 louis vuitton handbags nike factory outlet RoadEO converse pas cher longchamp outlet online he nike roshe abercrombie or ray ban,ray ban sunglasses,rayban,ray bans,ray ban outlet,ray-ban,raybans,ray ban wayfarer,ray-ban sunglasses,raybans.com,ray ban sunglasses outlet,rayban sunglasses,cheap ray ban reebok shoes she longchamp soldes ugg explained. michael kors uk hermes handbags The babyliss pro air max pas cher guy cheap michael kors the north face was prada outlet ferragamo shoes first ugg australia jimmy choo shoes dissatisfied jordan 11 burberry outlet online around prom dresses 2014 juicy couture outlet his new balance chanel handbags / prada handbags vans her chi flat iron burberry bat bottes ugg pas cher wedding dresses 2014 berrel montre pas cher longchamp outlet manage jordan pas cher coach purses they karen millen montblanc strike ralph lauren uk new balance outlet a jordan retro abercrombie fitch couple nike air max supra for sale and burberry ralph lauren also soccer shoes michael kors seemed polo outlet longchamp pas cher they ugg boots clearance nike air max will converse insanity present longchamps hollister achieved

canada goose outlet nike store sac longchamp pas cher converse shoes marc jacobs roshe runs roshe run mulberry uk sac burberry nike air max michael kors bags abercrombie kids oakley sunglasses,oakley vault,oakleys,oakley sunglasses cheap,oakley.com,sunglasses outlet,cheap oakley,cheap oakley sunglasses,oakley outlet,cheap sunglasses,oakley prescription glasses,fake oakleys,oakley sunglasses outlet,oakley glasses,oakley store,fake oakley,oakley sale,cheap oakleys,discount oakley sunglasses uggs outlet vans ugg boots clearance asics gel ugg boots uk kate spade outlet hollister pas cher louis vuitton outlet online supra shoes prada handbags oakley sunglasses,oakley vault,oakleys,oakley sunglasses cheap,oakley.com,sunglasses outlet,cheap oakley,cheap oakley sunglasses,oakley outlet,cheap sunglasses,oakley prescription glasses,fake oakleys,oakley sunglasses outlet,oakley glasses,oakley store,fake oakley,oakley sale,cheap oakleys,discount oakley sunglasses ugg boots coach factory outlet longchamp bags ugg boots ferragamo outlet kate spade outlet ray ban nike air huarache gucci handbags louis vuitton outlet kate spade coach outlet store online tory burch roshe run nike free canada goose jackets michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors outlet,michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet online,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,michaelkors.com,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors michael kors pas cher tiffany's bottega veneta prada outlet uggs the north face

Post a Comment
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
(not publicly displayed)
Reply Notification:
Website:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image:
* Message:

Email to Friend

Fill in the form below to send this oped to a friend:

Email to Friend
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
* Friend's Name:
* Friend's Email:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image
* Message: